Steven Wilson – Requiem for a Village


I’m going to need you all to stop bothering Steven Wilson about making a progressive rock album again. Please, just stop. If Requiem for a Village is the progressive rock he’s capable of making right now, I personally just want him to go back to his synth pop stuff. Because that’s way better. This annoying album released back on November 6th.

Steven Wilson is a giant of the progressive genre, from Porcupine Tree and Blackfield to Storm Corrosion and No-man. His solo works have drawn both adoration and disdain from his diehard fans. For this album, he handles vocals, violin, oboe, drums, guitars, bass, keyboards, sampler, percussion, and programming: bringing with him David Tennant and Andy Partridge on narration, Randy McStine on guitars, Russell Holzman on drums, and Katherine Priddy on vocals.

Okay, so Steven’s solo albums have always been a little more eccentric, more of a departure from his popular works. His first couple solo albums were pretty odd, honestly. But then he released the album that ruined his career: The Raven That Refused to Sing. It features two of his best songs ever (“Drive Home” and the title track), plus a bunch of noodly bullshit that set fan expectations for the foreseeable future. Sure, Hand.Cannot.Erase. is a classic, but mainly because he found a way to soak the progressive rock in pop sensibility, and its best moments are emotionally-driven. But the subsequent albums veered completely away from progressive rock into pop, and I rather liked them. But the fans did not, for the most part.

He came back to progressive rock with 2025’s impromptu The Overview, which I also liked, but now he’s back with his worst solo album and one of the most irritating albums of the year. Requiem for a Village is full of narration, spinetingling moments, storytelling, and colorful keys, but also annoying lyrics, guitar work that never goes anywhere, and tracks that I forget exist most of the time.

It sounds great. Yes, it does. The performances are flashy and highly skilled. The mix is pretentiously well done. But there’s something about the lingering start-stops of Steven’s current guitar phrasing that I find absolutely infuriating. Part of it is Randy McStine’s involvement, I’m convinced, because I dislike his solo albums for that exact reason. The whole album seems to be teasing us with a cinematic climax that never happens. There are lots of squirrely noodles to be had, but none of it goes anywhere. It spins its wheels for track after track. But, again, it’s all mixed very well.

So there are good things about the album. I appreciate the creepy vibe somewhat. I like the melancholy moments. A perfect example is “Murmuration” with its dark landscape of sound. I like the title track, too, being the early and basically only guitars-wide-open moment on the album. Pretty cool track, though the album pilfers and languishes from there, mostly. I also like “On Chapel Slope”, a slower ballad with hovering ambience. I find myself singing that one sometimes. I even like “The Same River Twice”, which is also more of a ballad with some nice keys.

You’ll notice that two of the four tracks I liked were singles. That’s because Steven chose to release the best songs on the album ahead of release. When I listened to the full thing, I was shocked at how much “nothing” inhabits the rest of the album. I don’t necessarily mean the narration tracks, like “Swirl in a Lark’s Eye”, or the piano interlude “Hiraeth”. No, I just mean that the rest of the main album tracks go nowhere and offer almost nothing.

The album basically ends on a whimper. “Wheel” tries to save it, but it just feels like an obligatory instrumental with a little energy, but I feel like I’ve heard it a million times in the classic prog rock bands of yesteryear. “The Old God Is Buried” is a track I was looking forward to, but I ended up being confused since it’s basically just chanting that also goes nowhere.

Speaking of repetition, “Now Departing” really bothers me. While it has some interesting ambient segments, I find the chorus incredibly annoying. I don’t know if it’s because it feels like Steven is rhyming “here” with itself, but even though it only occurs twice in the song, it feels like far more than that. I’m not sure why that is.

Look, I don’t want to yuck someone else’s yum. There are some truly rock-solid moments to be had on this album, and I don’t like writing negative reviews anyways. But I’ve really struggled to find this album beautiful in any fashion. It almost leaves me feeling filthy and covered in grime, and not the good kind. I can’t shake the feeling. I end up disliking it more every time I listen.

_____________

Find Steven Wilson online:

Facebook

Website

YouTube

_____________

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.